I had a conversation with AWAKE MUSLIMS on the topic above on one of his thread which he deleted due to embarrasment.
Now they have raised few things to take the attention away from this...I told them i have no time now till 24th Oct. 2011 ....
Afterwards I will make a response on their new polemics....
But in that mean time, I wish that readers may judge the conversation me and Awake Muslims had and conclude that who is correct.
And I wanna issue a challenge to Islamic brotherhood to disprove me if they can. Running away showing the backs is not the right issue.
Note :- Awake Muslims words are in bold
" shame on you for telling this and acting according to your own words.
instead of explaining you simply shown your dishonest and sickness again...."
Response:- Aha, calm down Awake Muslims, your frustration won't be going to help you anymore. I know that you did control but somehow your limit crossed.....Let us see :-
" are they ignorant are YOU? bible http://bible.cc/john/3-16.htm "
Response :- Anyone can be easily mistaken and not a matter of surprise that many if strong and other did....
Dr James R. White explains this here :-
" Dr. James R. White notes,
The key element to remember in deriving the meaning of monogenes is this: it is a compound term, combining monos, meaning only, with a second term. Often it is assumed that the second term is gennasthai/gennao, to give birth, to beget. But note that this family of terms has two nu’s, νν, rather than a single nu, ν, found in monogenes. This indicates that the second term is not gennasthai but gignesthai/ginmai, and the noun form, genos. G. L. Prestige discusses the differences that arise from these two derivations in God in Patristic Thought (London: SPCK, 1952), 37-51, 135-141, 151-156.
Genos means "kind or type", ginomai is a verb of being. Hence the translations "one of a kind," "one and only," "of sole descent." Some scholars see the -genes element as having a minor impact upon the meaning of the term, and hence see monogenes as a strengthened form of monos, thereby translating it "alone," "unique," "incomparable."
An example of this usage from the LXX is found in Psalm 25:16,
turn to me and be gracious to me,
for I am lonely (monogenes) and afflicted: (NASB)
(White, The Forgotten Trinity [Minneapolis, MN, Bethany House Publishers, 1998], pp. 201-202, fn. 27)"
Source :- http://answering-islam.org/Who/jesus_monogenes.html......
Dr White has bought forth a quotation from Septuagint i.e Psalm 25:16....
Septuagint is the greek translation (from Hebrew) of the biblical books and Psalm was originally written in Hebrew. Google it for more information
Secondly the word in Psalm 25:16 which is lonely in septuagint is MONOGENES .....
" Look upon me, and have mercy upon me; for I am an ONLY (MONOGENES) child and poor. " Psalm (25:16)
This is the english translation of the Septuagint which can be accessed here :-
http://ecmarsh.com/lxx/Psalms/index.htm.....
I recommend the whole of the article may be read for the better understanding ......
Monogenes actually means only (which implicates one of its own kind or Unique).....
So its a wrong translation i.e begotten just as most of the english translators of the Qur'an have translated the arabic word Awaliyah in Qur'an (5:51 ) as friends whereas keeping the things i.e 5:82 in consideration , it should be patrons and protectors although it does have multiple meanings.....
But this is not the case with Monogenes....
Then you say :-
" In bible even though word is there it does not mean that and we should blindly believe and accept it but in Quran which a word is not there you shameless added and showing your hater mind and telling me to be not dishonest.... i have been explain you word by word and shown enough proof on this that it does not speaks about any sexual intercourse and it clearly rejected that kind of thought in that verse but i never know your mind will be so crooked you make me feel chatting with you is vain and i wasted my time. "
Response :- First of all if i had been a hateful, then i would have not been talking in this manner rather would have abused you.....You have seen how i behaves when i gets out of control.....
Secondly . although the word is there in the english translation but in a few like KJV, NIV and few others, ' monogenes ' is translated AS ONLY which i the correct one as what Dr James R White explains above.....
And let us see the whole case :-
" Had We intended to take a pastime (i.e. a wife or a son, etc.), We could surely have taken it from Us, if We were going to do (that)." Qur'an (21:17 ) Al Hilali- KHAN
Although the words Wife , Son are in parenthesis but its supported by the tafsir which also reveals the circumstance when this ayah was revealed :-
" Then Allah revealed the following, when they said that the angels are Allah's daughters: (If We had wished to find a pastime) if We wished to have daughters; and it is said that this means: if We wished to have a wife; and it is also said that this means: if We wished to have children, (We could have found it in Our presence) from Us from among the maidens of Paradise (if We ever did) and We will never do this."
Tafsir Tanwîr al-Miqbâs min Tafsîr Ibn ‘Abbâs on Qur'an (21:17 )
Source :- http://www.altafsir.com/Tafasir.asp?tMadhNo=0&tTafsirNo=73&tSoraNo=21&tAyahNo=17&tDisplay=yes&UserProfile=0&LanguageId=2.......
Let us analyze the things here :-
(1) Ibn Abbas who was one of the cousin of your prophet and a scholar of Qur'an according to Islamic sources only informs us that this particular ayah was revealed when the pagans said that Angels are Allah's daughter as can be read above ......
(2) Then Allah replied to them through this ayah that :-
" (If We had wished to find a pastime) if We wished to have daughters; and it is said that this means: if We wished to have a wife; and it is also said that this means: if We wished to have children, (We could have found it in Our presence) from Us from among the maidens of Paradise (if We ever did) and We will never do this"
The circumstance is very important here that when this ayah was revealed.
So Allah says that had he wish to have children , then he could have surely got them from among the maidens of paradise.....
(3) Allah had to take one of the maidens as his wife and begat children because he himself says that he cannot be a father without a wife :-
" He is the Originator of the heavens and the earth. How can He have children when He has no wife? He created all things and He is the All-Knower of everything." Qur'an (6:101) Al Hilali- KHAN
So if Allah says that he cannot have children without a wife and at the other instant says that had he wished to have children , then he could have surely got one of the maidens as his wife and begat children....
(4) So if that is the case, then doesn't it gives an impression that Allah is capable of begetting although he doesn't do or will never do but he is capable of doing so ?
Let me know.....and then judge me brother what i did speak that :-
" Allah of Qur'an is only capable of having sexual intercourse which Qur'an 21:17 reveals. And this is corroborated by Ibn Abbas' tafsir on the ayah. Further Allah of Qur'an can be a father only through sexual intercourse (QUR'AN 6:101)"
Then you say :-
" in above you have asked me exact quotation for which you asked from bible to show and said dont show double standards... here you have shown more than that by including your sick mind.
you are really acting like hypocrite if NOT than show me where this word "sexual intercourse" is there in the quranic verse you cited above ???"
Response:- Yes i did not provide any quotation before but now i have provided the same in support of what i asserted or still asserts pertaining to Monogenes .....
Secondly what you have bought forth is nothing but an erroneous or a wrong translation of Monogenes ........
I have provided you with the scholar's opinion and i also quoted from the Septuagint in support of what i said ......
Thirdly your approach is an erroneous and a dishonest one....I am really sick of your dishonesty brother....
If i may say that bring the word ' Tawheed ' from the Qur'an, then i will believe that Islam really teaches Tawheed.
Then you will bring Surah 112 (Ikhlas) and explain that Ahad and Wahad means one of number only single which somehow establishes the doctrine of Tawheed that God is only one in number or in personality .
In the same way if had proved FROM YOUR OWN SOURCS that God of Qur'an requires a wife to beget children (although he doesn't do so as what he says in 112:3), so how will be having children from his wife (6:101) if not through a SEXUAL INTERCOURSE ?
Answer me ......if you are really truthful and honest....
Then you again did not refrain from your erroneous and dishonest approach and said :-
" you just show me the WORDS instead of twisting "
Response :- My brother in humanity, first of all i did not twist but only presented the things using your own sources.....
A statement can be made in many ways ....
For illustration if i may have to say that I had sandwich in the breakfast this morning, then i can do the same in the following ways :-
(1) Today i had sandwich in the breakfast.
(2) Today i ATE sandwich in the breakfast.
Now the first statement is devoid of the verb whereas the second one has a verb I.E ATE.....yet both gives us the same meaning....
AND IT IS NOT THE TWI STING RATHER SPEAKING THE SAME HING THROUGH TWO DIFFERENT WAYS..
Likewise if Allah says that he cannot have children without a wife (Keep the tafsir of Ibn Abbas on 21:17 and Qur'an 6:101 in mind), then doesn't this implicates that he requires to have copulation in order to beget children ?
Its not twisting but the simple understanding.....
So disprove me if you can
No comments:
Post a Comment